Governor orders Nevada to join health reform suit
by Oskar Garcia, Associated Press Writer
Apr 06, 2010 | 710 views | 4 4 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Nevada Governor Jim Gibbons
Nevada Governor Jim Gibbons
slideshow
LAS VEGAS (AP) — Gov. Jim Gibbons signed an executive order on Tuesday for Nevada to join 14 other states suing the federal government over health care reform.

The Republican governor said the state would be represented by Las Vegas lawyer Mark Hutchison after Democratic Nevada Attorney General Catherine Cortez Masto refused an earlier directive from Gibbons to join the multistate challenge to the health bill passed by Congress and signed by President Obama.

"Overall, the bill is unconstitutional and should not be allowed to stand," Gibbons said at a news conference where he signed the order.

The measure will cost Nevada taxpayers $2.4 billion in additional state and federal taxes, Gibbons said.

But Masto has said any outcome to lawsuits over the bill would apply to Nevada whether it joins or not.

Masto's office did not immediately return messages from The Associated Press seeking comment.

Hutchison said Nevada's objections to the law will be similar to other states, but he said the suit will be stronger with Nevada taking part.

"The constitutional questions which are raised by this litigation are going to be pretty much universal across the state lines, I think," he said.

"It's always a better lawsuit and judges always pay more attention when there are more parties involved," Hutchison said. "When you've got one state that's fighting the federal government it's one thing. But when you've got 36 states that are fighting the federal government it's another."

Gibbons said the state will pay less than $5,000 to join the lawsuit, which is filed in federal court in Pensacola, Fla. He said the cost was worthwhile given the cost of the legislation if it stands.

Hutchison will not be paid to represent the state, but he said he imagines the work will require hundreds of hours per month.

Gibbons said the move was not political, even though he faces a tough bid this year for re-election.

"Unfortunately, the Constitution is neither Republican nor Democrat and that answer should be that the Constitution is primary and supersedes any consideration of politics," Gibbons said.

"We have to do this," he said. "It is a must for the executive branch to undertake this litigation."
Comments
(4)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
anonymous
|
April 08, 2010
You are so out to lunch, Try reading what it says.

The health care bill will cost the state a alot more.

Hes looking out for the state more then the AG or reed ever did
anonymous
|
April 08, 2010
Who will pay for this private attorney ? Nevadans ! Are we not in a deep enough financial hole for this Governor ? Must he dig us in deeper for his political grandstanding? The AG has aready said any outcome from the other 14 lawsuits will effect all the states. What is the point of wasting more money we do not have. How about spending it on getting the states unemployment rate down? Or boosting the education budget. These are the things we are worried about right now. Not a federal law that will not affect us for several years. Come on, Jim. Look out for the people in this state.
anonymous
|
April 08, 2010
He means the state will have to pay. We dont have the money to pay for this.

Thank God he is standing up for Nevada.

It's time people stand up and say no more to this government,Dump Reed and the AG
anonymous
|
April 08, 2010
I didn't know Nevada paid STATE taxes???

What's he talking about?

report abuse...

We consider the comments section of www.dailysparkstribune.com to be a key part of a constructive community dialogue. Your comments will appear as you type them. The Daily Sparks Tribune does not prescreen contributions to the comments section. Individuals posting libelous statements may be held responsible.